Messed up screw on M9A3– need help sourcing exact replacements.

Gotten myself into a bit of a pickle here. I sniped this beauty a couple weeks ago— M9A3 Italy. Absolutely love it. Unfortunately, when I opened it up to swap the mag release over to the right (I’m a lefty) I marred up one of the screws putting the grips back on. Wasn’t using the proper tool.

I’ve ordered replacement screws from Hogue and Beretta both with the same issue— they lack the “shiny” finish on the screw they’re just matte. I get I’m really splitting hairs here but I love the shiny screws and my OCD is tripping with the marred screw.

Anyone know or can direct me to the proper screws? Promise to use the correct tool this time.

Thanks, SK