Which NYC hotel which you stay at given these rates?

Taking the wife up to NYC for a quick weekend trip to celebrate her birthday. Looking to stay somewhere a notch above your average hotel in the $250-$400 range. She wants to do Central Park so looking for something walking distance to there. Here are the options I’m considering and rate I’d pay:

JW $387 Le Meridian $330 Luxury Collection Hotel $321 Renaissance $297

For those that have stayed at these, which do you feel provides the best value based on these prices?

I recently got Platinum so bonus points if they have decent breakfast and M lounge or if I’d be more likely to get an upgrade based on suite inventory