It was obvious Garrett and Jared were the same person. Just me?

After 17 year old Garrett ghosts Roo and team when they were to meet in person, she randomly gets a new man messaging her with the same CP requests named Jarred. I immediately said "Jarred is Garrett, he knew he wouldn't be a believable 17 year old in person so he recontacted her as a 30 year old." I was so surprised it took the team up until they found his offer up profile to realize it's the same person. The shock on their faces was like none of them even suspected it. Am I the only one that is like come on guys this was an obvious one???